[1228]
I have a world of things to write to you: I do not know where to begin. It has been more than three weeks since I returned to Cairo; a secret reluctance flooded my soul, so that I could never bring myself to put my hand to a pen. And the cause of my reluctance to write to you is the opinion I have of Fr Lodovico and his Institution, which I am not brave enough to explain to you. Nevertheless I am resolved at last. You are my true friend, my master, the closest collaborator in the apostolate for the Africans. You know the depths of my heart: I would like to see 100 institutes sharing Central Africa to bring it all to Catholicism. If I let you know my view of Fr Lodovico, it is because I am convinced of it. I would be very glad to retract and to know that I was mistaken. I am speaking to you, who do not let anyone lead you by the nose and will sooner or later discover the truth of the matter on your own. God forbid that I should delude myself! But God is truth, I do not want to delude anyone. I must tell you what I feel in the depths of my soul.
[1229]
Fr Lodovico is a man of great charity, a true son of St Francis in observing the rule of his Order and the model of religious observance. But his head is not equal to his heart, and he is not clear and upright in his dealings. Fr Samuel of Negadeh, an old Missionary in Upper Egypt, a reformed Franciscan who accompanied us to Shellal, described Fr Lodovico as a combination of ignorance, charity, piety, hypocrisy, falseness and virtue. When I speak to you, a world of proof and facts; I now limit myself to telling you only this. The President of Shellal, Fr Bonaventura da Casanova, and Giuseppe Habaschy himself and all the Neapolitan Franciscan missionaries I saw in Egypt say that Fr Lodovico is a saint in his own way. The President of Shellal and our Habaschy gave me a clear picture of the real substance of his Institution; I compared it with Fr Lodovico’s explanations, and with a letter he wrote to the Grey Friars which I translated for him into Latin because he had ordered it to be read once a week to the whole community; and all this, together with what I observed in Fr Lodovico, leads me to form this opinion: “Fr Lodovico’s Institution will be unable to do a thing in Africa unless it is directed and governed by the First Franciscan Order”. Probatur.
[1230]
The Grey Friars are a motley bunch of laymen of every kind and trade who show an inclination for piety, that Fr Lodovico clothed as Franciscans in order to direct and instruct young people in crafts. As long as they prove pious, recite rosaries and genuflect, he gives them a habit and involves them in the Works. Then with equal facility he deprives them of their habits and throws them out on the street. He receives and clothes six laymen and seven leave and become seculars. The Father Provincial of Naples and all the friars are up in arms against Fr Lodovico who makes such a mess of politics and of the community that he publicly jeopardises the Franciscan Order as a whole. Fr Lodovico’s Institution can have tertiary Priests; but for the moment he has not yet formed a single one. He therefore needs 1st Order Franciscans, without whom his Institute cannot function. One after another, none has been able to come to terms with the ideas of Fr Lodovico who wants his Institution to be the only Franciscan one to administer the Works.
[1231]
The fact is that he now has 42 craftsmen in both Europe and Africa and he wants to run the Works in Naples and Africa independently of the 1st Order. I am not telling you anything about their instruction, which is unknown at La Palma. Fr Bonaventura of Khartoum who is the best trained member of Fr Lodovico’s Institution, confessed to me that he knew little more than what he learned in Verona. He knows nothing of dogmatic, or moral [theology]. So the good man, after small tests, exposes the members to the Works and to the Missions and puts them in a position where they risk damnation. We now come to Africa. In the past, he sent 12 individuals to Africa. Two have died, one… as you know… is a gas-lighter in the public streets of Naples; and all the others have deserted his flag. Two of them who are here in Cairo, assure the friars that they will never go back to Fr Lodovico. Let us come to our expedition. In Shellal we left:
Fr Bonaventura da Casanova, President
Fr Bonaventura of Khartoum Fra Pietro, carpenter and Procurator
Fra Innocenzo, infirmarian
Fra Giovanni, a young African and
Fra Lodovico, craftsmen whom we dressed as lay brothers in Trieste.
[1232]
The President, who belongs to the First Order and has nothing to do with Fr Lodovico’s Institution, is a good friar; but he is not convinced of either Fr Lodovico’s brains or Work: this will do Fr Lodovico good.
[1233]
Fra Pietro was a soldier for seven years and fought against Garibaldi in 1860; then as a carpenter, he was the Director of the Capodimonte factory in Fr Lodovico’s Institute, one of the greatest members of La Palma.
Fra Innocenzo is really good, he is the best one in Shellal. He is well able to care for the sick, and is intent on healing and administering medicine. You saw the others in Brixen.
[1234]
Now in Shellal he ordered that they should keep the same life-style as at La Palma. Choir, silence, solitude, etc. (there are only two priests). He forbade the President from communicating either with Propaganda or with the General or with the Provincial on pain of being abandoned and not sending him provisions. Well! Listen to this… On the 15th of this month, to my enormous surprise, I see Fra Pietro, Procurator in Shellal appear before me. I am astonished. The fact is, he has sworn never to set eyes on Shellal again. He had a vocation for just 28 days; and then it left him. In a word, there is a terrible split between the two friars who are Priests. The President does not know one iota of Arabic. Giuseppe Habaschy must deal with business although he is his inferior. Now according to what Fra Pietro said to the friars, it seems that our Habaschy, puffed up by the welcome and friendship which those in Shellal have shown him, is seeking to get himself support to oust the President and make himself superior of Shellal. He has never been in Choir; he rented land without speaking to the Superior, and wrote to me for money; he opens the Superior’s letters, he has money which he has borrowed, despite the prohibition of Fr Lodovico who forbade him to touch money; all in all, there is total chaos in Shellal.
[1235]
From what I saw, I thought it would take the two friars six months to split up. Fr Samuel gave them only two months: instead, they did not remain peacefully together for even a fortnight. I immediately wrote to the President, advising him to stay firmly where he was in accordance with Fr Lodovico’s orders, and I wrote a tremendous letter to Bonaventura of Khartoum in which I spoke to him as a true father. I hope it will have a good effect. Then in sending the President’s letter to Naples, I wrote a letter to Fr Lodovico as a true friend, and repeated the advice I had given him on the Nile, not to be too hasty in ordaining Africans priests, and not to expose his Institution to large enterprises without testing each individual’s vocation over a long period. In a little while, Fra Pietro said, the two Africans will also leave. It is useless. Without the 1st Order, Fr Lodovico’s Institution will get nowhere. The Father Provincial in Naples, very familiar with the situation, said to Fr Lodovico: “If you want Missionaries to direct the Station of Shellal I will give you the best and ablest members of the Province”.
[1236]
Fr Lodovico refused. And do you know why? He said it himself: because he wants to present one or two positive facts to the Holy Congregation of Bishops and Regulars, so that they will approve his Institute, and the King of Naples is its Protector. But neither the Holy Congregation nor the General Administration of the Franciscans want anything to do with it. Now I say with many: this man is not seeking Africa’s good: he is seeking glory for his Institute. In Africa we could have many excellent Franciscan Missionaries; and Fr Lodovico is preventing it. His Institution, which does not yet have a single Priest, is lagging behind: it is a miracle if it can keep Shellal on its feet, because it has no members, only craftsmen who have no vocation. But enough of that; something else which will astound you.
[1237]
The chief enemy of my Plan is Fr Lodovico; and what is most annoying, he is extremely hostile and opposed to Propaganda granting the Institute a piece of Africa. I am fully informed, and G. Habaschy actually heard it, that Fr Lodovico did all he could in Rome to hinder the division; he even begged Cardinal Barnabò to stop me following him to Africa, but the Cardinal replied: No, I want Comboni to go with you, I order it, and I desire the division. In Naples he had said to me: “I and La Palma would like to be your servants and to co-operate with your Plan”. He came to Verona and expressed Propaganda’s wishes to Fr Tomba, he said he wanted to help the Institute, etc. You will know it precisely from Verona: he came to Brixen, and there you know how he talked to you.
[1238]
We went to Vienna. While I was absent for two days in Prague with His Excellency Archbishop Schwartzenber, he presented your most beautiful project for the division to Fr Matzek and begged him to influence the Committee to oppose the division. This is what he said: “If we can do good in Cairo and Khartoum, why should we give the tribes on the White Nile to others? It would be better for the moment to refuse the Mazza Institute a part of Africa”. This in fact is what he decided. This was told me ad litteram by Giuseppe of Khartoum, who heard it personally. I did not believe it, but from subsequent events I am certain that this is how it went.
[1239]
Having boarded the steamer in Trieste, as soon as we set sail this is what Fr Lodovico said tome: “My son, I would think it would be prudent not to discuss the division in Egypt with the Bishop, nor with the friars, nor with anyone, for they will all make fun of us: let us go to Shellal, and then on our return we will discuss it with the Bishop”. Then I added, “How will you justify my having accompanied you to the Franciscans? Do the Franciscans need priests to found their Missions?” Then he answered me: “I will say that you came with me as a friend who is acquainted with the works in La Palma, and also to give me your assistance since you know Africa well”. I acquiesced to his wishes, on condition that on our return from Shellal we should stay for a while to confer with the Bishop in accordance with Propaganda’s orders.
[1240]
I say nothing of his habit of adding a few words to denigrate my Plan by saying, “Comboni’s Plan is lovely in theory; in practice, impossible” and he would say this to the most distinguished persons. I do not mention that armed with recommendations to consuls, personalities, etc., here in Egypt he never introduced me as a friend to anyone, although I asked him for an introduction to one of them; whereas in Verona, Vienna and Trieste, I introduced him to all the benefactors of the Mission and all my acquaintances. I say nothing of countless other slights in his behaviour to me, which I am ashamed to relate. Perhaps I will tell you a few of them in person, at least for a laugh. I say nothing of his way of talking about past Missionaries in Central Africa: the greatest praise he could give Knoblecher was: “Oh! he was an affluent man… missions must be built with humiliation and not with money, etc.” Let’s come to Shellal.
[1241]
We inaugurated Shellal on the day of Epiphany. Since Prince Antonio Hohenzollern Sigmaringen turned up there, on the evening of the 8th I obtained a free passage on the steamer as far as Cairo. It was to sail on the morning of the 9th. In the evening I summoned Fr Samuele of Negadeh who accompanied us to Shellal and with Fr Francesco, Fr Lodovico’s nephew, we entered Fr Lodovico’s room and this is what I said: “The purpose for which Propaganda wished me to come with you to Shellal and to Egypt was to come to an agreement together about the division of the Vicariate Apostolic of Central Africa, and to deal with Monsignor the Apostolic Delegate in Egypt. You are leaving tomorrow. When you arrive in Cairo you leave for Europe on the first ship; we can no longer discuss this most important matter of the division together”. “What matter?”, he replied, “I know nothing about it”. I retorted: “But what did Cardinal Barnabò tell both of us? What did he say to you when you passed through Rome on your way to Verona? Didn’t he order both of us to go to Africa, etc.?” “I know nothing”, was his answer; “what do you want, since we are dust, we have our Superiors, should we decide on a matter of such importance? Let our Superiors do it; I know nothing. Where are your letters etc. which say that we are authorised to make this division that you are talking about? I know nothing about it”… In short, my dear friend, he denied everything; he covered me with a barrage of hypocritical gossip, praising Fr Mazza’s Missionaries, but saying that there was no money, etc.
[1242]
Then when I showed him your letter in which you wisely suggested the division into southern and northern, etc., he said: “Well, if Propaganda asks me, I will present this project”. He promised that he would wait for me in Cairo to discuss it with the Bishop so that, should we fail to speak to the Apostolic Delegate, Propaganda would not oblige us to return to Egypt for the same purpose. But the fact is that when he arrived in Cairo he did not mention it at all to the Bishop and departed for Naples. He said that in Central Africa what was needed was St Francis’ humility and poverty. His theories are lovely and good: but in practice they are different. He is the first ecclesiastical egotist that I have ever seen in my life; the one that will give me more trouble than everybody else when it comes to introducing other Institutes into Africa. He, who has not one actual candidate (with the exception of a few craftsmen, who were already craftsmen when they joined his institute), intends nothing less than for no one go to Africa; fair enough if he obstructed only the Mazza Institute; but he has agreed with the General that no other Franciscan can enter (Africa), if he is not from La Palma. My dear, this is just a 10th part of all that I have seen and have to tell you about Fr Lodovico. I would only like to add the false programme published in the Catholic papers A new direction etc. Good heavens! Either I was the being made fun of by Cardinal Barnabò and the Pope and the General, all three of whom promised me a Mission for the Institute and sent me to Africa for this purpose, or Fr Lodovico is an impostor. Think about this new direction given to the African Missions; and form your opinion.
[1243]
In spite of all these deep disappointments, I spent the most peaceful days with Fr Lodovico from 26th October to 8th January, without ever the shadow of a doubt, just as a loving son would spend with his father. Despite Fr Lodovico’s proceedings regarding me and anyone working for Africa, I will always do what good I can for him. Except, for the good of Africa, I would like to have a long talk with the Father General of the Franciscans. I am telling you how I feel about it, because you must not be fooled as I was fooled all the times I went to Naples. But now I have dealt with the man, I have seen what is positive in him, I have heard what good Neapolitan friars had to say to me; and only now, with supreme sorrow, have I opened my eyes. I would be glad to be mistaken, because Africa would find powerful assistance in Fr Lodovico. But I fear instead that Africa will benefit from him little: I have come to know the man thoroughly, and enough. Let us come to Khartoum.
[1244]
I have spoken to nine or ten traders in Khartoum and with one voice they all speak ill of the moral conduct of Fr Fabiano. He has 22 slave girls who have escaped from the Muslims. Some masters are protesting that he obtained their slaves through the Austrian consul; but he does not react. He has no doings with outsiders, he gets drunk on eau de vie from morning to night, etc. and lives like a Muslim with his slave girls. These are the rumours which the rascally traders are spreading about Fr Fabiano. I do not believe any of them; and I consider Fr Fabiano innocent. But what is positive in all this is that the Consul Hansal has sent a tremendous report to the Consul General of Egypt, who showed it all to me, even the Father’s feeble defence of himself. Now the Consul General is sending a report to the Minister in Vienna, charging the Missionary: the Consul tells me that at the Mission, which is in the small house in the garden where the slave girls live, three mulatto babies were born, and all Khartoum believes… Fr Fabiano writes to the Consul General that a few slave girls are necessary to the Mission to make bread. The fact is that he is a priest alone and exposed to these calumnies, without having been able to confess for a long time, etc. I write this to you, as Father of the Mission, so that should you be able to remedy the matter and verify it, and do something positive for Fr Fabiano, you may do so. I have begged the consul not to write to Vienna, but instead to get in touch with the Bishop of Egypt.
[1245]
The railway from Cairo to Aswan has already been begun, and in a few years the stretch from Aswan to Khartoum will be completed. Other railways between Suakim and Berber will connect the Nile with the Red Sea. It takes only a month now to go from Cairo to Khartoum via Suakim. Another 3,000 soldiers have left for Sudan, and three great Egyptian provinces will be formed on the White Nile. The Prussian Protestant school in Khartoum is flourishing, and is frequented much more by the European colony than the Catholic one. In Assiut there is another Anglican school. What will be the results of these events on the faith? I wrote a short report on them to Barnabò.
[1246]
I am convinced, and so are all the Missionaries of Egypt, that the application of the Plan for the Regeneration of Africa in Upper Egypt is one of the most suitable ways to be of use to Central Africa. Since the saga of the division is going to be somewhat drawn out (and of course it will be effected according to your idea, as the wisest and fairest), I therefore feel I am doing something useful by founding two small Institutes, a female one in Negadeh and a male one in Kenne; with the double objective of serving Egyptian Coptic youth and at the same time, preparing elements for the Africans.
[1247]
For this purpose I have diligently visited all the spots in Upper Egypt where there is a Catholic Station. On reaching Cairo, I presented a small project to the Prefect Apostolic of Upper Egypt, in which I suggested strengthening this Mission by applying my Plan for the Regeneration of Africa. The Prefect, urged by all his Missionaries, accepted my proposal and submitted it to Cardinal Barnabò. So I wrote a very nice letter to the Cardinal and among other things, requested him to authorise me to found a small Institute in Negadeh, where I would bring in whichever Sisters His Eminence preferred. I will also form another small group of African girls in Cairo, under the care of the Sisters who live there. But on this point I shall write to you in detail with the next steamship.
[1248]
Likewise, I will send you a short account of our journey to Shellal. The famous and interesting conversation I had with Lesseps, who gave me wise advice on how to apply the Plan, etc. Fr Lodovico arrived in Naples on 27th January. He will open a house teaching crafts in Old Cairo, which will be directed by his Priest nephew; something which vexes the friars here in Cairo. He acquired a house near the cemetery, under the obligation of celebrating just one Mass a week. The director of studies will be that African Morsal, whom I took to Naples in ’62. But a further explanation about this.
[1249]
The Father President of Shellal asked me to send him money. I left Fr Lodovico with 4 gold Napoleons. Fr Francesco sent him another 30 thalers from Cairo. One of the reasons why that President will stay firmly in his place is the hope that he will not lack what he needs. It is therefore of capital interest to the Mission to help him. If he is given assistance, he will stay put even on his own. Therefore, if you can, make sure you help him as soon as possible. But it would be better if you sent the money directly through the Consul and Fathalla, because there is a risk it would be intercepted in Naples as happened last Autumn. The President told me that several hundred of these New Directions were being disseminated in Naples and also proclaimed by Habaschy and himself in churches, and that 500 scudi were collected: these were then mixed in, as both the priests of Shellal told me, with Fr Lodovico’s craft work. Our Superior in Verona had the same little defect. Thus the President advised me: “If you can give me aid, let me have it directly, and I will account to you for everything”.
[1250]
I am staying in Cairo until the middle of Lent; I then go to Verona via Rome where I must discuss things with Propaganda. In Verona I fetch the African girls and take them back to Egypt. So please take care of our little African boy Lokwis, whom with Kachwal I should like to take with me to Egypt. But first I must empty all my thoughts into your heart and act on your advice.
[1251]
I do not want to waste time; I want to work and live for Africa alone, and for the conversion of the Africans. I hope that God will help me and grant me great graces, and that you will always be my father, counsellor, friend, master and everything. I fear nothing, I trust in God. A thousand respects to his Reverend Highness, and to his Secretary, to the master of the African, to the African, etc.
Tuissimus in corde et opere
Fr Daniel Comboni