[1933]
I have delayed answering your respected letter of 13th June, firstly in order to give mature reflection to its content, in accordance with your wise advice, and secondly because I deemed it necessary to respond with facts to the crucial point of finding and arranging a separate house, which cost me so many steps, humiliations, expenses and efforts that, with heaven’s assistance, have been crowned with success. I think that I will be able to give you a complete answer to the four points mentioned in your letter, commenting on a few observations Your Excellency was kind enough to inform me were made by the Sacred Congregation of Propaganda Fide.
[1934]
To begin with, it does not seem to me that the Most Eminent Cardinal Barnabò was too exact in his judgement that my Institute lacks solid foundations. Your Most Reverend Excellency knows full well that it has the same foundations as most new religious Institutions, except for the ownership of property, buildings and land; and that it has the firmest hope that these foundations, planted in the broad bosom of Providence who governs events and time, will prove to be sound. Indeed this hope rests on the paternal protection of Your Most Reverend Excellency whose consent to its very existence and whose firmness and charity in protecting its existence are the surest guarantee of it’s being well-founded.
[1935]
Secondly, you are aware of the quantity and quality of the protection afforded by the government of Her Majesty the Empress of France. Thirdly, its form and the aims it pursues are such that it cannot and must not arouse doubts or fears from any of the other moral entities in loco, which have so far shown benevolent participation. Its aim is absolutely clear: the evangelisation of Africa. So much for external issues.
[1936]
As regards the internal management, the female Institute is supported by the collaboration of the Sisters of St Joseph of the Apparition, whose rule was approved by the Church, whose Protector is the Most Eminent Cardinal Prefect of Propaganda. The male Institute at the moment has four priests of good will and health, who are not lacking in the adequate gifts to fulfil the obligations of their ministry. And in the case that I should die, or that the small Verona Seminary were completely unable to supply suitable replacements, should you deem it appropriate, you could count on the collaboration of the Camillian Order to pursue the Work.
[1937]
Furthermore, my Institute has always had Rules and Timetables complying with the norm of other Institutes, but with those particular features that foster the speciality of its objective. It has started and is carrying on its task in favour of the poor Africans who are a prey to all miseries.
[1938]
As regards its means of sustenance, my Institute has the full support of the most serious and strongest sympathies from the pious Associations approved by the Church for aid to the Catholic Apostolate and from illustrious and powerful benefactors whom I know personally.
1. The Cologne Association for the Redemption of Africans has pledged in writing 5,000 francs a year; verbally 10,000 and in fact, in a year and a half, has contributed 18,300 francs.
2. The Propagation of the Faith of Lyons and Paris, (thanks to Your Excellency’s most efficient intercession), allocated 5000 francs, with the promise to increase the amount as the Work developed.
3. There is hope of support from the Associations of St Ludwig in Munich (it has made two offerings totalling 1,500 francs), of the Immaculate Conception for the East in Vienna (has given 100 francs), of the Holy Sepulchre in Cologne (has given 500 francs), of the Schools of the East in Paris (has given 200 francs), of the Holy Childhood, of St Francis de Sales, and of the Apostolic Societies in Rome, Lyons and Paris, etc., etc.
4. It has the daily Mass intentions of the Missionaries, of whom there are now four.
[1939]
5. In a short time it was able to collect, almost without asking, 9,642 francs from private benefactors, the most prominent of which are Her Imperial Majesty and Royal Highness Empress Marianne in Prague, His Highness the Prince Royal of Saxony and his august spouse, Prince Löwenstein (who on 11th April deposited one million at the feet of the Holy Father), Prince Alessandro Torlonia, Baron Havelt, Cardinal Prince Schwartzemberg, the Cardinal Archbishop of Vienna, the Crown Princess of Portugal, etc., etc., etc.
6. From the French government, which in my two expeditions of 1867 and 1869 allowed me to save more than 11,000 francs in passages and the free shipping of goods; I expect a strong contribution from their oriental fund, as I have been given to hope by several heads of the Department of Foreign Affairs.
7. The Institutes are equipped with household goods, kitchen utensils, linen and religious vestments and objects worth more than 20,000 francs.
[1940]
As regards the house, Your Excellency knows to what lengths I have gone to get it free of charge from His Highness the Viceroy, equipped as I was with valid recommendations. Despite so many obstacles and rejections, and the unfavourable spirit which reigns generally regarding the poor Africans, I have good hopes of availing myself shortly of two houses, either through the generosity of the Egyptian government or with funds that Providence will put into my hands. In any case, hic et nunc the Institutes have two houses paid up for one year and a third house paid up for more than six years. The male House (which we call after the Sacred Heart of Jesus) is more than 800 paces from the Institute entrusted to the Sister of St Joseph (which we call the House of the Sacred Heart of Mary); and is 175 paces away from the School directed by Mother Caterina Valerio T.F. (which we call the House of the Holy Family).
When these Institutes in due course extend their activities towards Central Africa, to which they are specially destined, I hope Your Excellency will let us make use of one of the Houses already existing in this vast Vicariate. To all this I must add that the range of sources of subsidies on which I can seriously count in future is much more vast and more widespread, should the Work develop as it ought.
[1941]
Insofar as I have always yearned for crosses, as healthy and necessary for the growth of holy works, and kind Jesus having always been generous in these despite my unworthiness, I have pleasure in adoring in complete resignation the dispositions of Providence who has allowed our respected Most Eminent Cardinal Prefect with his wit to put a rather heavy brake on my resources, since he let it be known to many that Comboni was crazy, a madman fit to be tied, etc. This rumour spread through Rome, went round Italy and France and may even have reached Germany and cooled or restrained some people, and was a powerful influence in making me refrain from certain steps which, during my last trip to Europe, would certainly have earned one hundred thousand francs.
[1942]
From these facts and hopes it does not appear to me that I should conclude that my Institute lacks sound foundations. Quite a number of other mission establishments have less solid foundations than my Institute, which after all has only existed for 18 months, and in such a short time it has resisted so many and such great storms that if it had not had solid foundations, it would have crumbled long ago.
[1943]
In this context, the Most Eminent Cardinal’s other proposition does not appear altogether exact to me either, namely that through lack of adequate regulations there had been the improprieties that were generally referred to him. The organisation of my Institute, attentis specialibus circumstantiis, was most proper. From the beginning it had most appropriate Rules suited to the place and to the objectives. It had its Timetables for daily activities as well as for times of spiritual practices, for monthly retreats, etc. and these regulations were and still are observed. I have in my possession a handwritten letter from that Zanoni, who was the only perpetrator of those deplored improprieties, in which he declares that the internal and regular organisation of my Institute were unbearable, too strict and for Carthusians.
[1944]
If the lack of regular organisation had been the cause of the improprieties which occurred, they would not have been perpetrated only by an old religious of 49, but much more probably by a young man of 28 and another of 22. But of these two good companions of mine, who could have said or can say a word against their behaviour save the unfortunate Zanoni, who realised himself that he was unworthy of living among them and just under a year ago went away from them in the manner Your Most Reverend Excellency knows about? It was therefore not a lack of regular organisation: it was one of those evil arts with which God allows the devil to test his Works so that they may be strengthened and hell may be vanquished. Judas among the Apostles, Br Elia alongside the Seraphic Patriarch, apostasies in the heart of the Church and the Religious Orders, etc.: can these be said to have happened through lack of regular organisation?
[1945]
It is grievous for me to see that in some way the faults of an individual are being attributed to my Institute in general. Improprieties existed; but in the accuser, not in the accused. I therefore wish His Eminence would see in this a completely different case, as in fact it is; and instead of repeatedly throwing the blame on the Institute, that he should see its real innocence alongside an unworthy treachery which falsely charges others with its own crimes. Nor can the Most Eminent Cardinal Prefect accuse me of imprudence in entrusting Zanoni as I did with the direct supervision of the female Institute. That old man had a white beard and was 49 years old, for over 15 years he had had important responsibilities and had been the Prefect of one of his Order’s houses in Mantua. In my judgement this was a sufficient guarantee that Zanoni could be trusted; and to tell the truth I would have had more trust in him than in myself. But may the Lord be blessed forever, who through this fact was pleased to give me a great lesson which will be most useful in helping me to regulate my actions ever more cautiously in future.
[1946]
Lastly, coming to the explanations Your Most Reverend Excellency was kind enough to ask of me concerning Fr Guardi, the Camillian Order and my two companions Carcereri and Franceschini, to whom the venerable observations and insinuations you had from His Eminence refer, here are the genuine facts. In March 1867, like all the other Orders in Italy, the Ministers of the Sick were suppressed. Fr Carcereri and Fr Franceschini, not wanting to do what some of the others did and return to their own families, asked with two of their companions to be sent to the foreign missions, which they had been wanting to do for some time. Fr Guardi was then the Procurator General and, seconding the wishes of the Provincial, he denied them his consent at that time, advising them to wait and see what would happen.
[1947]
In the meantime the Bishop of Verona, having heard of their intentions, thought he could make use of them for Africa and supported the request they made to the Holy Father through the Sacred Congregation for Bishops and Religious, not without informing His Holiness explicitly and exactly about the refusal these supplicants had received from their General. This request was granted by means of the Pontifical Rescript of 5th July, which placed the said Fathers under the jurisdiction of the Bishop of Verona ad quinquennium. Their Superiors were still opposed to their departure however, and tried to recall them several times after their arrival in Egypt. The Most Eminent Cardinal Barnabò himself, urged by Fr Guardi who is a close friend of his, in a letter of 15th September last, insinuated to Carcereri and Franceschini that they should return. In view of so much insistence from the most venerable Cardinal Prefect and from Fr Guardi, who had become the Vicar general of the Camillians, I was gripped by the serious fear that I would lose for Africa, not only these two men who understand the importance of our Work so well, but a few others of the same Order who possess the same gifts and are disposed to engage themselves in the difficult apostolate of Central Africa.
[1948]
That is why I seriously began to meditate and examine with our dear Fr Stanislao ways of reconciling the good of Africa and the interests of my new Work with the Most Eminent Cardinal Prefect’s declarations and Fr Guardi’s reasonable desires. We therefore imagined that, should it please Your Most Reverend Excellency, it would be most appropriate if little by little, either within the walls of the male Institute or not far away, a small Camillian House were created in adiutum to the Institutes for Africans. It could specifically assume the care for the sick with the intention that, when this Work is sufficiently developed, at a later stage, the Order of the Ministers to the Sick could be put in charge of the evangelisation of one of the thousands of African tribes in central Africa. It would then be easy for our Work to allocate a part of its resources.
[1949]
This was the thought, Monsignor, that I intended to mention in one of my latest letters to you. It is a thought we have carefully meditated on and which in our opinion could lead us to a most reasonable and satisfactory solution as well as being laden with great benefits for Africa. That was what we thought: Fr Carcereri mentioned it at the beginning of this year to Fr Guardi: but then nothing more was said or done. That is all. I therefore do not see why Fr Guardi should speak of initiative, for nothing was ever asked of him, and of compromising his Order, for he was never approached officially by anybody, neither on behalf of my Institutes, nor of the Mission.
[1950]
As for Fr Carcereri and Fr Franceschini, neither do they consider themselves as ever having been detached from their Order, indeed basing themselves on their Rescript, they fought with Fr Guardi who was threatening to consider them as such; nor were they, or are they, considered as detached from their Order by me, or by the Bishop of Verona, or by anyone that I know of. I therefore find myself in the same condition as His Eminence of not knowing on what basis or by whom Carcereri and Franceschini are seen as being detached from their Order. I am also in a position to assure Your Excellency that neither the Bishop of Verona nor I have taken any steps in this regard with that illustrious Order.
[1951]
Our lives depend on the grace of God and the protection of Your Most Reverend Excellency. However difficult the enterprise to which we have consecrated ourselves to may be, and which we intend to bring to fruition; however furious the storms we may encounter, with the support of the Lord and Your Excellency, we fear nothing. In the meantime we persist in our prayers. Christ’s treaties are more solid and secure than all the treaties of worldly powers; therefore petite et accipietis is more solid and secure than the Vienna treaty of 1815, than the 1856 Paris treaty, than the 1867 Nikolsburg and Prague treaties and even than the Convention of 15th September 1864, etc. Atqui prayers are being said everywhere for our Work: therefore we will succeed fully in our efforts, non obstantibus mundo et diabolo.
May Your Most Reverend Excellency deign to receive with bounty my heartfelt thanks, also for your most welcome and venerated letter of the 19th. We all humbly implore your pastoral blessing, while in the most profound
veneration and gratitude, I remain,
Your Most Reverend Excellency’s
most humble, devoted and unworthy son
Fr Daniel Comboni